1958 Football All-Stars
West Football All-Stars
Coach: K.K. Sems, Union
| Player | School |
| Tiffon Mayfield | Weintert |
| Stanley Mayers | Knippa |
| Gene Murrell | Jayton |
| Archie Scribner | Mobettie |
| Ruben Vaughn | Gail |
| Johnnie Gottle | Harper |
| Melvin Foster | Sterling City |
| Martin Young | Spade |
| Warren Heagy | Imperial |
| William Brazee | Guthrie |
| Fred Brooks | Mertzon |
| Allen Ray Baldwin | Valentine |
| James Massingill | Gail |
East Football All-Stars
Coach: J.W. Massengale, Sidney
| Player | Address |
| J.W. Grigsby | Elysian Fields |
| Ronnie Smith | Miles |
| Norman Dickey | Gunter |
| Donald Bird | Divide |
| Robert Barnett | Fairy |
| Howard Pinion | Gunter |
| Marvin Hayes | Hamshire |
| Billy Bomar | Talpa |
| Tom Echols | Ira |
| Rodney Webb | Coolidge |
| Max Reed | Sidney |
| Gary Rowland | N. Side |
| Paul Gordon | Miles |
| Adrian Parks | Trinidad |
| William Heaton | Hamshire |
| Bob Hardy | New Waverly |
| Ray Lowe | Goodrich |
1958 Boys Basketball All-Stars
West Basketball Team
Coach: Jay Cox, Weintert
| Player | Address |
| Earl Faulkner | Leabey |
| Denny Large | Leabey |
| Carl Williams | Water Valley |
| George Allsup | Medina |
| Bobby Duboise | Jayton |
| James Goldsmith | Boaker |
| Robert Webb | Flower Grove |
| Dan Chrane | Pyote |
| Loyd Klose | Mattson |
| Don Hunt | Channing |
| Billy Trainhan | Benjamin |
East Basketball Team
Coach: Gerald Williams, Goodrich
| Player | Address |
| John Ross | Lone Oak |
| Beall Orr | Devine |
| Junior Rothenberger | China |
| Frankie Clayton | Devine |
| Charlie McLain | Klysian Fields |
| Dale Van Donn | Sabine Pass |
| Ted Watson | Jonesboro |
| Pat Holcomb | Trinidad |
| Jerry Ray | Miles |
| Jerry Bell | North Side |
| Albis Stutville | Gustine |
